Section 89A: how returning NRIs avoid double taxation on 401(k), IRA, and foreign pension withdrawals

A software engineer returned to India from the US in 2022 after 11 years on H-1B. They had accumulated $420,000 in a Fidelity 401(k) and $85,000 in a Traditional IRA. During their RNOR period (2022–2024), these accounts weren't taxable in India. In FY 2025-26, they became a full Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR) taxpayer.

Their financial advisor told them: "Your 401(k) distributions are now taxable in India as foreign income." The engineer withdrew $40,000 from the 401(k) to fund a home renovation. Fidelity withheld 30% ($12,000) for the IRS. When the engineer filed their Indian ITR, they included $40,000 (₹33.6 lakh at prevailing rates) as foreign income — adding ₹33.6 lakh to their already sizable Indian salary income. Effective Indian tax on the 401(k) distribution came to ₹10 lakh.

They had paid $12,000 (≈₹10 lakh) in US withholding and ₹10 lakh in India. On a $40,000 withdrawal, effective total tax was approximately $24,000 — a 60% total rate.

Section 89A exists precisely to prevent this. Had they filed Form 10-EE, the Indian tax on the 401(k) distribution would have been deferred — payable only in the year the US taxes it, with a credit for the US tax already paid.

---

What Section 89A does

Section 89A of the Income Tax Act (inserted by Finance Act 2021, effective from AY 2022-23) provides that income accruing in a notified account in a specified country shall be taxed in India only in the year in which such income is taxed in the foreign country — not in the year it is received in India.

In plain terms: if you receive a 401(k) withdrawal in India, you do not include it in Indian taxable income in the year you receive it. You include it in the year the US would tax it (which, for a 401(k), is the year of withdrawal — same year). You then claim a foreign tax credit for the US tax withheld.

The mechanism:

1. File Form 10-EE before your ITR due date
2. The 401(k)/IRA income is excluded from Indian taxable income in the receipt year
3. In the year the US taxes it (often the same year), you re-include it in Indian income
4. You claim a Form 67 foreign tax credit for the US withholding tax

The net effect: Indian tax applies to the net income after the foreign tax credit. No double taxation.

---

Notified countries and accounts (as of 2026)

CBDT has notified the following countries and account types under Section 89A:

Country	Account types covered
United States	401(k), 403(b), Traditional IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA
United Kingdom	Employer-sponsored occupational pension schemes
Canada	RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan), RRIF (Registered Retirement Income Fund)

Not currently notified (as of 2026):

• Australia (superannuation funds — frequently requested but not yet notified)
• Singapore (CPF — Central Provident Fund)
• UAE (DEWS / GPSSA — no India-UAE DTAA retirement provision)
• Germany, France, Netherlands pension schemes

If your retirement account is in a country not on the notified list, Section 89A does not apply. You must report the income in India in the year received and claim any available DTAA relief separately.

---

The eligibility conditions

Section 89A applies only when ALL of the following are true:

1. You are ROR (Resident and Ordinarily Resident) in India in the year of withdrawal
2. The account was opened while you were a non-resident — i.e., when you were living abroad and not an Indian tax resident
3. The account is in a notified country (US, UK, Canada currently)
4. The account is a notified retirement account (401k, IRA, RRSP etc. — not a regular brokerage account)
5. You have filed Form 10-EE before the ITR due date for the relevant year

Key condition: opened as non-resident. A 401(k) opened by an H-1B visa holder while living in the US qualifies — the person was non-resident of India during that period. A 401(k) that somehow existed while the person was an Indian resident would not qualify (extremely rare).

---

How 401(k) withdrawals are taxed: the US side first

Understanding the US tax treatment is essential because Section 89A synchronises Indian tax to it.

Traditional 401(k) and Traditional IRA:

• Contributions were pre-tax (deducted from US income when contributed)
• Growth is tax-deferred
• Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income in the US in the year of withdrawal
• For non-US residents withdrawing: US withholding at 30% (or 25% under India-US DTAA Article 20) applies at source
• No penalty for age 59½+ withdrawals; 10% early withdrawal penalty if under 59½ (+ US income tax)

India-US DTAA Article 20 (Pensions): Article 20 of the India-US DTAA provides that pensions paid to a resident of India shall be taxable only in India — the US should not tax it. However, 401(k) distributions to non-US-resident Indian nationals are treated by US custodians as subject to 30% NRWHT unless you specifically file a W-8BEN and claim Treaty Article 20. Many Indian returnees do not do this and pay the full 30% unnecessarily.

To claim Treaty rate: File Form W-8BEN with your US 401(k) custodian before the withdrawal, claiming residency in India and Article 20 benefits. Many plan administrators reduce withholding to 0% or 25% under the DTAA — but this requires proactive filing. Call the custodian and ask specifically about DTAA withholding rate reduction.

---

The Section 89A mechanism: step by step

Year of withdrawal (example: FY 2025-26)

Without Section 89A:

1. You withdraw $40,000 from 401(k)
2. US withholds $12,000 (30% or reduced DTAA rate)
3. You receive $28,000 in your Indian bank
4. You include $40,000 gross (= ₹33.6L at ₹84/USD) in Indian taxable income
5. Indian tax at 30% slab = ₹10.08L
6. You claim FTC via Form 67: US tax of $12,000 (= ₹10.08L) as credit
7. Net Indian tax = ₹10.08L − ₹10.08L = ₹0 (roughly)

This sounds fine — but the problem arises when the US DTAA rate is 0% or lower than your Indian slab rate. If you successfully claimed Article 20 Treaty exemption and the US withheld 0%, there is no FTC to claim, and you owe the full Indian slab tax on the $40,000 with no offset.

With Section 89A:

1. You withdraw $40,000 from 401(k)
2. US withholds $12,000 (or 0% if Treaty claimed)
3. You file Form 10-EE before ITR due date
4. The $40,000 is excluded from your Indian taxable income in FY 2025-26
5. In the same year (FY 2025-26), the US taxes the withdrawal
6. You re-include the $40,000 in Indian income in FY 2025-26 (same year, because US and India tax it in the same year)
7. You claim FTC via Form 67 for the US tax paid
8. Net Indian tax = Indian tax − FTC

The mathematical result may be similar to just claiming FTC directly. The key benefit of Section 89A emerges in timing mismatches — where the US taxes the income in a different year than India would otherwise tax it (e.g., deferred compensation arrangements, annuity structures, pension backpay).

---

Roth IRA: the unsolved problem

The Roth IRA has unique characteristics that Section 89A does not cleanly resolve:

US treatment: Qualified Roth IRA distributions are 100% tax-free in the US. There is no US withholding on qualified Roth distributions to non-residents. There is no US tax in any year.

Section 89A mechanism: Defers Indian tax to "the year the income is taxed in the foreign country." If the foreign country (US) never taxes it — there is no triggering year.

The problem: Without Section 89A deferral and without US tax paid to credit, an ROR Indian taxpayer receiving Roth distributions faces:

• Indian tax on the full withdrawal as foreign income
• No FTC (because no US tax was paid)
• Effective taxation of Roth distributions at Indian slab rates (up to 30%)

Current CBDT/income tax position: As of 2026, there is no explicit exemption for Roth IRA in Indian tax law. The India-US DTAA Article 20 applies to "pensions" — whether a Roth IRA qualifies as a "pension" under Article 20 is unsettled.

Practical approach: Many professionals argue that the contribution amounts (already taxed in the US) should be returned tax-free in India (basis recovery), and only the growth component should be taxable. This is analogous to how India treats other after-tax savings structures. But this is not explicitly codified — it requires a case-by-case DTAA analysis.

Roth IRA holders returning to India: Get explicit professional guidance before making withdrawals as an ROR taxpayer. Do not assume Roth = tax-free in India.

---

Practical guide to managing 401(k)/IRA as a returning NRI

Before you return: the RNOR planning window

Your RNOR period (typically 2–3 years after returning, depending on your prior history) is when retirement account withdrawals are most tax-efficient in India. During RNOR:

• Foreign income from assets held before you returned is not taxable in India (it falls outside RNOR scope under Section 6(6))
• 401(k) and IRA withdrawals made during RNOR are typically not taxable in India
• Section 89A is not needed during RNOR — you don't need it because the income isn't taxable in India anyway

Strategy: If you anticipate needing liquidity, make significant 401(k) withdrawals during your RNOR window. A ₹1 crore 401(k) withdrawal during RNOR may have zero Indian tax consequence, while the same withdrawal after becoming ROR faces Indian slab tax minus FTC.

Confirm your RNOR status for each financial year with a tax advisor before relying on this strategy — RNOR is determined by your specific residency history, not just your date of return.

After RNOR: the Section 89A regime

Once ROR, file Form 10-EE for any year you receive 401(k) or IRA distributions. The form requires:

• Details of the foreign retirement account (account number, country, institution)
• Income accrued or received during the year
• Whether the income was taxed abroad and in which year
• Claim for exclusion from current year income

File Form 10-EE before the ITR due date (July 31 for most taxpayers; October 31 for those with audit requirement).

Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)

US law requires 401(k) and Traditional IRA account holders to begin taking RMDs starting at age 73 (SECURE 2.0 Act). The RMD is calculated based on account balance and life expectancy tables. RMDs cannot be avoided — failure to take the RMD triggers a 25% US penalty on the required amount not taken.

For returning NRIs age 73+: RMDs create a recurring Indian tax event. Section 89A and Form 10-EE should be filed every year you receive RMDs. Over a 20-year RMD period, the effective annual Indian tax depends on your Indian income in each year, the FTC for US withholding, and whether you elect to claim DTAA benefits.

---

Schedule FA disclosure for foreign retirement accounts

Regardless of Section 89A, all Indian residents must disclose foreign retirement accounts in Schedule FA of ITR-2.

What to disclose:

• Account details (account number, institution name, country)
• Peak balance during the year
• Closing balance as of December 31 (US accounts use calendar year)
• Income accrued (even if not withdrawn)

Key error: Many returning NRIs report the 401(k) account balance in INR using the year-end exchange rate — but the Schedule FA asks for a calendar-year snapshot (Jan 1 – Dec 31), not the Indian financial year. The 401(k) balance as of December 31, 2025, goes into the AY 2026-27 Schedule FA (for FY 2025-26, which ends March 31, 2026 — the December 31 snapshot falls within that financial year).

---

Summary: Section 89A in plain numbers

Scenario	Without 89A	With 89A
401(k) withdrawal: $40,000	Included in Indian income: ₹33.6L	Excluded from Indian income if deferred to US-tax year
US withholding at 30%	FTC available: ₹10.1L	FTC available in the year re-included
Indian slab tax at 30%	₹10.1L	₹10.1L (same, if same year)
Net Indian tax	≈ nil (FTC offsets)	≈ nil
Timing mismatch scenario	Indian tax in receipt year regardless	Deferred to US tax year

The biggest value of Section 89A is not the numbers in steady state — it is the protection against timing mismatches where the US taxes pension income in a different year than India would otherwise tax it, and the protection against situations where no FTC exists (DTAA Article 20 Treaty claims that result in zero US withholding, leaving full Indian tax with no offset).

File Form 10-EE every year you receive distributions from a notified foreign retirement account. The cost of filing is near-zero. The cost of not filing — when a timing mismatch creates a double-taxation event — can be substantial.