Upstox vs Rovia for US stocks from India: GIFT City vs LRS, RSU tools compared
Upstox (GIFT City IFSC route, 0.25% brokerage, simpler transfer, potential Section 10(4D)) vs Rovia (LRS route, 0.15% brokerage, ACATS, lot-level RSU tax tooling). Full comparison for Indian investors.
Arnav GroverCo-Founder & Chief Product Officer, RoviaShort answer: Rovia if you have RSUs at a US employer broker. Upstox if you're a pure cash investor who already uses Upstox for Indian stocks and wants simpler international transfers.
How the platforms are structured
Rovia uses the LRS route with Alpaca (US FINRA-registered broker-dealer) as custodian. Purpose-built for RSU management:
- 0.15% brokerage per trade (capped at $15 — verify at rovia.one/pricing)
- Inbound ACATS from Fidelity, E*TRADE, Schwab, Morgan Stanley
- Lot-level sell with HIFO/FIFO/LIFO selection
- Schedule FA automation (daily snapshots, peak INR balance export)
- ITR-ready realized-gain reports
- LRS route: SWIFT, A2 form, TCS above ₹7L/yr
Upstox uses the GIFT City IFSC route via Raise IFSC Pvt. Ltd.:
- 0.25% brokerage per trade (capped at $25, verify at upstox.com)
- Domestic NEFT/IMPS funding — no SWIFT, no A2 form
- No TCS on the outward transfer (standard LRS TCS rates still apply on aggregate LRS; verify with CA)
- Potential Section 10(4D) capital gains exemption — unconfirmed; verify with CA
- NYSE and NASDAQ listed securities; no options, no international exchanges
Head-to-head comparison
| Dimension | Rovia | Upstox (GIFT City) |
|---|---|---|
| Route | LRS (SWIFT) | GIFT City (NEFT/IMPS) |
| Brokerage | 0.15%, cap $15 | 0.25%, cap $25 |
| FX spread | ~0.9% (SWIFT) | ~0.3–0.5% est. (GIFT City) |
| Transfer method | SWIFT (3–5 days) | NEFT/IMPS (1 day) |
| ACATS inbound | Yes | No |
| Lot-level sell (HIFO) | Yes | No |
| Schedule FA export | Yes (automated) | Manual — verify in-app |
| Exchange access | NYSE, NASDAQ | NYSE, NASDAQ |
| USD withdrawal | No (INR only) | No (INR only) |
| Indian-time support | Yes | Yes |
| Existing Upstox users | Separate account | Same app |
Full financial year worked example: ₹15 lakh invested
Profile: Arun, no RSUs, invests ₹15 lakh/yr in US ETFs, already uses Upstox for Indian stocks
| Cost item | Rovia | Upstox GIFT City |
|---|---|---|
| Brokerage (~3 trades buy + sell) | ~₹3,375 (0.15% × ₹15L × 1.5) | ~₹5,625 (0.25% × ₹15L × 1.5) |
| FX spread | ~₹13,500 (0.9%) | ~₹6,000 (0.4% est.) |
| Transfer fee | ~₹2,500 SWIFT | ~₹0–₹50 NEFT |
| TCS above ₹7L (reclaimable, both routes) | ₹16,000 | ₹16,000 |
| Total non-reclaimable outflow | ~₹19,375 | ~₹11,675 |
Upstox saves ~₹7,700/yr for a pure cash ₹15L investor. The savings come from FX (NEFT vs SWIFT) and avoiding SWIFT fees — not from brokerage.
Upstox's FX spread is an estimate — verify in-app before each transfer. Rovia's ACATS and lot-selection tools add value that is not captured in this comparison for RSU holders.
Onboarding walkthrough
Rovia:
- Create account at rovia.one → PAN, Aadhaar, bank details, W-8BEN
- KYC + Alpaca account opening: 1–3 business days
- Fund via LRS SWIFT: A2 form, purpose code S0001; funds arrive in 3–5 business days
- ACATS: Transfers → Incoming ACATS; enter delivering broker + lots; settles 5–7 US business days
- Total time to first buy: 4–8 business days
Upstox:
- Download Upstox app (if you don't already have one for Indian equity)
- If you already have Upstox, activate US stocks in-app — KYC reuses existing credentials
- Fund via NEFT/IMPS to Upstox's GIFT City nodal account; funds available next business day
- Total time to first buy: 1–3 business days for existing Upstox users
What happens when things go wrong
SWIFT stuck at your bank (Rovia): LRS SWIFT transfers above ₹5 lakh may require additional bank documentation. Resolution: 3–7 business days. Prepare salary slips and ITR before initiating large transfers.
NEFT bounce (Upstox): NEFT to GIFT City fails when payee name doesn't match exactly. Funds return within 2 business days. Fix the payee name in Upstox's funding screen and retry.
Schedule FA — both routes: Rovia provides an automated Schedule FA export. Upstox's Schedule FA treatment for GIFT City accounts should be verified with your CA. Both routes require annual disclosure; do not assume GIFT City accounts are exempt.
Section 10(4D) — don't file preemptively: CBDT has not confirmed the Section 10(4D) capital gains exemption for retail investors on GIFT City platforms as of August 2026. File capital gains at the standard rate until CBDT issues a circular.
Investor personas: who belongs on which platform
Arun — existing Upstox user, ₹15L/yr ETFs, no RSUs Arun already uses Upstox for Indian stocks. The GIFT City US stock account reuses his KYC, and NEFT funding takes 1 day vs Rovia's SWIFT 3–5 days. The total non-reclaimable cost difference is ~₹7,700/yr in Upstox's favour. Arun belongs on Upstox.
Priya — RSU holder at E*TRADE, ₹30L vested, wants HIFO Priya's RSUs are at E*TRADE across 4 vest tranches. ACATS-in to Rovia lets her consolidate without selling. HIFO on a ₹30L portfolio saves ₹40,000–₹70,000 in capital gains vs FIFO on first full liquidation. Upstox cannot do this. Priya belongs on Rovia.
Vikash — starting fresh, ₹5L/yr, primarily mutual funds via Upstox Vikash wants US market exposure alongside his Upstox MF SIPs. He does not need RSU tools. Upstox GIFT City is the path of least resistance — same app, domestic transfer, no new KYC. At ₹5L/yr he is below the TCS threshold on either route. Upstox is the right choice.
Related reading
- Upstox vs INDmoney for US stocks
- Rovia vs Vested for US stocks
- GIFT City vs LRS: the complete guide
- RSU lot selection and tax-loss harvesting
Sources
Fee figures last checked October 2026. Verify before investing — fees change without notice.
- Rovia pricing (0.15%, cap $15) — rovia.one/pricing (Oct 2026)
- Upstox US stocks fee schedule — upstox.com/us-stocks (Oct 2026 — verify in-app)
- RBI LRS guidelines — rbi.org.in (Oct 2026)
- IFSCA regulations — ifsca.gov.in (GIFT City regulator)
Run your own numbers
Try the calculators that match this post
Frequently asked questions
- What is the main difference between Upstox and Rovia for US stocks? ▾
- Upstox uses the GIFT City IFSC route — domestic NEFT/IMPS funding (no SWIFT), no TCS on the outward transfer, and potential Section 10(4D) capital gains exemption (verify with CA). Rovia uses the LRS route and is purpose-built for RSU consolidation — inbound ACATS from Fidelity, E*TRADE, Schwab, Morgan Stanley, lot-level cost basis tracking, HIFO sell, Schedule FA export. If you have RSUs, Rovia is almost always the right choice. If you don't have RSUs, Upstox's simpler transfer mechanics and TCS-free outbound transfer are meaningful advantages.
- Does Upstox avoid TCS on US stock investments? ▾
- No. TCS applies at standard rates regardless of route — 0% up to ₹10L/year, 20% above. The GIFT City route does not exempt you from TCS. What Upstox's GIFT City route changes is the transfer mechanics: NEFT/IMPS instead of SWIFT, no A2 form required, and no LRS documentation overhead for the outbound transfer itself.
- Can Upstox receive RSU transfers from Fidelity? ▾
- No. Upstox does not support inbound ACATS transfers from US employer brokers. RSU shares at Fidelity, E*TRADE, Schwab, or Morgan Stanley cannot be transferred to Upstox — you must sell, repatriate, and reinvest, triggering a capital gains event. Rovia is the platform built for this use case.
- Which is cheaper — Upstox or Rovia for a pure cash investor? ▾
- Upstox's GIFT City route charges 0.25% brokerage. Rovia charges 0.15%. Rovia is cheaper on brokerage. However, Upstox's NEFT funding avoids SWIFT fees (~₹1,500–₹3,000/transfer) and the FX spread on GIFT City is typically 0.3–0.5% vs LRS SWIFT's ~0.9%. A combined cost comparison must include FX spread and transfer fees, not just brokerage.
Found this useful? Share it.
Help another Indian working with US RSUs or LRS not get blindsided by this stuff.
About the author
Co-Founder & Chief Product Officer, Rovia
IIT Bombay + IIM Calcutta. Founding PM at Aspora (largest NRI fintech). 6+ years covering Indian-resident US investing, LRS compliance, Schedule FA, and ITR-2 filing for AY 2026-27.
More about Arnav →Get more like this in your inbox
One practical post a week on US investing & RSU strategy.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Keep reading
Rovia vs Dhan for US stocks: LRS vs GIFT City, RSU tools vs simpler transfers
Rovia (LRS route, 0.15% brokerage, RSU consolidation) vs Dhan (GIFT City route, 0.25% brokerage, simpler domestic transfer, potential Section 10(4D)...
Zerodha vs Rovia for US stocks from India: GIFT City vs LRS, RSU tools compared
Zerodha (GIFT City IFSC route via Vested, 0.1% brokerage, simpler transfer) vs Rovia (LRS route, 0.15% brokerage, ACATS, lot-level RSU tax tooling). Full comparison for Indian investors.
NSE IX Global Access vs Rovia: which is right for Indian US stock investors?
NSE IX Global Access and Rovia both let Indian residents invest in US stocks under the LRS. The structural difference: GIFT City IFSC demat account...